Week 4 Part 2: What makes a website effective? What makes good design?

This week I'm reviewing two of the most well-known and widely used learning management systems, Canvas and Blackboard.  

Canvas and Blackboard are effective because they both do a reasonable job at organizing a lot of information, while providing interactive forums for discussion, project review, and live chats.  The sites have very similar designs: clean layouts with prominent, upper left-hand navigation menus.  Canvas uses a more inviting and fresher color scheme, which is superior to blackboard's more drab color schemes.  Design-wise, Canvas is slightly more minimalist at the onset, allowing the user t navigate to further details.  

While I imagine both Canvas and Blackboard are both trying to create well-designed and user-friendly sites, students keep coming back to the sites because they have to.  Personally, I have some classes that use Canvas and some that use Blackboard.  While I come back to both sites out of necessity, I actually appreciate using Blackboard slightly more, probably because I have used the site before.  Both sites could improve by integrating a navigation bar that follows scrolling.  Oftentimes, I will be at the bottom of the page and the navigation bar is still at the top of the page.  Additionally, Canvas has poor options for embedding a file in a discussion board; the user must navigate to his profile homepage, update the file, then navigate back to his discussion page. 


BLOG COMMENTS:

This week I reviewed the blogs of :

Stacy Brock  

Alexa Kent

Sujatha Nanduri

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Week 1A: My Template

Image
Ever since I was a kid I thought to myself, "simplicity of actions; complexity of mind."  Following this maxim, I chose a simple template for my blog.  I think that the dominant social media forums follow a similar idea: "simplicity of layout, complexity of content."  Indeed, I believe that social media forums like Instagram and Snapchat are successful due to their clean, streamlined, yet highly visual layouts.  In regards to my template, I plan on posting photos and short videos, accompanied by my own writing.  I believe that successful content engages the senses, sight being one of the most important.  Considering this, I look forward to creating simple, yet engaging posts using the simple layout.
Read more

Week 3: Communicating via Socials with Brands

A customer's communication with a business can end up creating an evangelist for the company, or an enemy of the brand.  I recently booked a trip to Cabo San Lucas on Alaska Air.  I was hoping to bring my surfboard and I had read a blog post that Alaska was now only charging a regular baggage fee of $25 for a checked surfboard.  I wanted to confirm that the baggage fee was indeed this low so I called.  After a short wait of a few minutes, I was pleasantly surprised to be able to speak to a representative who clearly and pleasantly answered my question.  Conversely,  a few weeks ago, I called Intuit with a question I had regarding my subscription to Quickbooks Online.  I had called Intuit before with a technical question and had been pleasantly surprised with the high level of customer service and technical knowledge.  Unfortunately, on this call, I was connected with somebody who was difficult to understand, possibly due to a language barrier....
Read more

Week 4: Aesthetics, Design, and Branding _ Website Analysis

Does a good website create a good brand or is it the other way around? Having recently designed a website for a startup, I enjoyed the opportunity to analyze the do's and don'ts of other sites.  I looked at 4 websites total, 2 sites to critique for problems and 2 to critique for successes.  It seemed that both pairs of sites either failed or succeeded based on how they organized and presented the relevant information. To start, let's look at 2 sites that could use some improvement.  I reviewed the two sites: www.roverp6cars.com www.gatesnfences.com Both of these sites create an information overload for viewers.  For each of the sites, the home pages are structured as if they were a page in a catalog, versus as an effective table of contents or launch point for information.  Both of these sites could benefit from having a more cleanly laid-out, better organized homepage, thus better helping visitors in their searches.  Another issue thes...
Read more